Last updated: August 23, 2026
Every feeding pillow thread on the internet ends up here. Two products dominate the category, they have almost nothing in common beyond their purpose, and the people who love one tend to be baffled by the people who love the other. That is not brand loyalty talking, it is two genuinely different designs suiting two genuinely different situations.
This is the comparison without the sponsorship. What each one is built to do, who ends up happy with which, and the specific circumstances where the answer is obvious rather than a matter of taste.
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
Quick Answer
Boppy or My Brest Friend?
- My Brest Friend if your back and shoulders ache while feeding, or after a C-section.
- Boppy if you want a soft, versatile cushion that also props things up around the house.
- My Brest Friend if the pillow keeps sliding out of position when you move.
- Boppy if storage, weight and casual use matter more than a perfectly level shelf.
Bottom line: firm shelf and posture, or soft cushion and versatility. Both are supervised feeding products and neither is a sleep surface.
Two Different Design Ideas
The Boppy is a soft, curved cushion that rests around your waist without fastening. It is light, it is easy to move between rooms, and it is used for far more than feeding. The My Brest Friend is a firm, flat topped platform that buckles around the waist and includes a panel that supports the lower back.
Those two descriptions contain the entire argument. One is a versatile cushion that happens to be good at feeding; the other is a feeding device that is good at nothing else. Which framing appeals to you is usually the answer.
Firmness and Height
The My Brest Friend is firmer and flatter, so the baby sits on a level surface at a consistent height and stays there. The Boppy is softer and curved, so it compresses under weight and the effective height drops as the baby grows. That single difference drives most of the divided feedback.
If you are finding that you lean forward to meet the baby, or that you are propping the pillow with a folded blanket, you are describing the problem the firm design exists to solve. If you have never noticed the issue, the softer cushion is doing its job.
Best if the shelf keeps collapsing
The firm flat platform keeps its height under load and does not need a blanket underneath, which is the difference people notice fastest when they switch.
Back Support and the Buckle
The My Brest Friend’s distinguishing feature is a back panel that wraps around and fastens at the front, pulling you upright instead of letting you round forward. The manufacturer describes the design around posture, and owner feedback consistently mentions the back panel as the reason for choosing it.
The belt has a second effect that gets less attention: the pillow stays with you when you stand up. That matters more than it sounds, because standing up with a baby and having the pillow fall off is the small daily irritation that ends a lot of relationships with a soft cushion.
The trade you are making
Buckling on a pillow every time is a step, and some people find it too much apparatus for a night feed. The Boppy asks nothing of you: you sit down, you put it on, you feed. Whether the extra second is worth the extra stability depends entirely on whether the stability is a problem you have.
Versatility Around the House
This is where the Boppy wins outright. It is used as a back prop, an arm rest, a lounging cushion for adults and a general purpose pillow long after feeding is over. Many households keep one in the living room indefinitely and never think of it as a feeding product again.
The My Brest Friend is not that. It is a purposeful object that gets stored when it is not being used, and it takes up more space than a cushion. If you like things that do several jobs, that will count against it.
Best if you want a cushion that stays useful
The soft crescent is light, easy to carry between rooms and the one people report still using around the house long after feeding has finished.
Safe Use Applies to Both
Neither pillow is a sleep product. The Consumer Product Safety Commission has warned about infant deaths involving nursing pillows used for sleep or lounging, and the American Academy of Pediatrics safe sleep guidance is that babies sleep alone, on their back, on a firm flat surface with nothing else in it.
Use either one only for supervised feeding while you are awake, never leave a baby unattended on one, and move the baby to a safe sleep surface if they fall asleep. The Boppy’s versatility around the house does not extend to sleep, and the full detail is in nursing pillow safety.
Side by Side
| Feature | Boppy | My Brest Friend | Matters if |
|---|---|---|---|
| Firmness | Soft, compresses | Firm, holds height | You lean forward to feed |
| Fastening | None, rests in place | Buckled belt | You stand up mid feed |
| Back support | No panel | Wraparound panel | Your lower back aches |
| Other uses | Many, all around the house | Feeding only | Storage space is tight |
Both come with removable washable covers and both have spare covers available, though the covers are not interchangeable between brands.
The Situations With a Clear Answer
After a C-section, the firm belted design is the one most people prefer, because it takes the baby’s weight off the lap rather than resting it close to the incision. For twins, neither standard model is wide enough and you want the dedicated twin version. For feeding in a variety of chairs and rooms, the light cushion is easier to live with.
For everyone else it comes down to a single question: is the pillow you have now sliding, sinking or leaving your shoulders sore? If yes, go firm. If you have no complaints, the soft cushion is a perfectly good default and a more useful object in the long run.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use both? Plenty of people do, keeping the firm one where they feed most and the soft one on the sofa. It is not extravagant so much as a recognition that they do different jobs.
Which is better for a tall person? Neither adjusts much, so if standard heights have never fitted you, look at the adjustable designs instead. Our feeding pillow guide covers those.
Does the belt fit every body? Both brands make larger and deluxe versions with longer straps or more generous dimensions. Check the listed measurements rather than assuming, since this is a common source of returns.
Which is easier to keep clean? Both have removable covers. The soft cushion is quicker to strip and rewrap; the firm one has more structure to work around. A spare cover solves it either way, see covers and spares.
Can either be used for bottle feeding? Yes, both, with a small change in positioning. See feeding pillows for bottle feeding.
Best if you want the firm design with more room
The deluxe version of the belted pillow adds a pocket and a more generous strap range, which is the practical fix for anyone who found the original strap short.
If feeding hurts, if the latch is not working or if positioning is the underlying problem, a lactation consultant will help more than either pillow. No cushion fixes a positioning issue, and it is worth asking sooner rather than persevering.
The Bottom Line
Choose the firm belted pillow if posture, sliding or a collapsing shelf are your problems, and choose the soft crescent if you want a light, versatile cushion you will use for years. After a C-section the firm one is the usual answer; for twins neither standard model is wide enough. Both are supervised feeding products only. Read next: the full feeding pillow guide, and the safety rules.